Relationship with President — Amendments

Amendment	Year	Description	Impact
42nd Amendment	1976	Made the President's action on ministerial advice explicitly binding by changing Article 74 to state that the President 'shall' act in accordance with such advice, removing the previous ambiguity. Also added that questions about ministerial advice cannot be inquired into by courts.	Definitively established the Prime Minister's supremacy in executive matters while preserving the President's constitutional dignity. Eliminated debates about whether the President could refuse ministerial advice and clarified the binding nature of the aid and advice mechanism.
44th Amendment	1978	Restored some balance by requiring written advice from the Council of Ministers for the proclamation of emergency under Article 352, ensuring that the President's emergency powers involve proper consultation with the Prime Minister and cabinet.	Strengthened the consultative aspect of the PM-President relationship in emergency situations while maintaining the binding nature of ministerial advice. Enhanced the role of collective responsibility in crucial constitutional decisions.

Also build Paper II skills

Dense constitutional and IR passages mirror CSAT-style comprehension and argument evaluation—build those skills in parallel. CSAT hub.

• Valid & invalid arguments
• Syllogisms
• Critical reasoning