Supreme Court upholds 103rd Constitutional Amendment providing 10% EWS reservation
November 2022
The Supreme Court's 3:2 majority decision upholding the 103rd Constitutional Amendment demonstrates the Constitutional Framework's continued evolution to address contemporary social justice needs. The amendment, which provides 10% reservation for Economically Weaker Sections (EWS) in education and employment, represents a significant shift in India's reservation policy by introducing economic criteria alongside social criteria. The judgment examined whether the amendment violated the basic structure doctrine, particularly the principles of equality and the 50% reservation ceiling established in Indra Sawhney case. The majority opinion held that economic classification is constitutionally valid and that the amendment doesn't violate basic structure, while the minority opinion raised concerns about breaching the equality principle. This development illustrates how the Constitutional Framework adapts to changing social needs while maintaining constitutional principles through judicial interpretation.
UPSC Angle: Expected questions on constitutional amendment process, basic structure doctrine application, reservation policy evolution, and the balance between social justice and equality principles. Relevant for both Prelims (factual aspects of 103rd Amendment) and Mains (analysis of constitutional interpretation and social justice).