Supreme Court — Basic Structure

Basic Structure

The Supreme Court of India, established on January 26, 1950, is the apex judicial institution with 34 judges including the Chief Justice of India. Located in New Delhi, it replaced the Federal Court and serves as the guardian of the Constitution and fundamental rights.

The Court exercises three types of jurisdiction: original (exclusive disputes between governments), appellate (appeals from High Courts), and advisory (non-binding advice to President). Its most significant power is judicial review, enabling it to examine the constitutionality of laws and executive actions.

The basic structure doctrine, established in Kesavananda Bharati (1973), limits Parliament's amending power. Judges are appointed through the collegium system (CJI plus four senior judges) and retire at 65.

Key constitutional provisions span Articles 124-147, covering establishment, appointment, powers, and jurisdiction. Landmark judgments include Kesavananda Bharati (basic structure), Maneka Gandhi (Article 21 expansion), S.

R. Bommai (Article 356 guidelines), and recent cases on privacy, triple talaq, and Article 370. The Court can issue five types of writs under Article 32 and has pioneered Public Interest Litigation. Current challenges include case pendency (70,000+ cases), collegium transparency, and balancing judicial activism with restraint.

Recent developments include AI-powered case management, live streaming of proceedings, and increased women's representation. The Court remains central to Indian democracy as the final interpreter of the Constitution and protector of citizens' rights.

Important Differences

vs High Courts

Aspect	This Topic	High Courts
Constitutional Basis	Articles 124-147 establish Supreme Court as apex court	Articles 214-231 establish High Courts for states/UTs
Jurisdiction	Original, appellate, and advisory jurisdiction nationwide	Original and appellate jurisdiction within state/UT boundaries
Appointment Authority	Collegium of CJI + 4 senior SC judges	Collegium of CJI + 2 senior SC judges + HC Chief Justice
Retirement Age	65 years for all judges including Chief Justice	62 years for all judges including Chief Justice
Binding Nature	Decisions binding on all courts in India under Article 141	Decisions binding on subordinate courts within jurisdiction

The Supreme Court stands at the apex of India's judicial hierarchy with nationwide jurisdiction and final authority on constitutional interpretation. While High Courts serve as the highest judicial authority within their respective states/UTs, the Supreme Court's decisions are binding on all courts including High Courts. The Supreme Court's unique advisory jurisdiction and exclusive original jurisdiction in inter-governmental disputes distinguish it from High Courts. Both courts exercise judicial review, but the Supreme Court's interpretation of the Constitution is final and authoritative.

vs Federal Court of India

Aspect	This Topic	Federal Court of India
Period of Operation	January 26, 1950 onwards (continuing)	October 1, 1937 to January 25, 1950
Constitutional Status	Established by Indian Constitution as apex court	Established by Government of India Act, 1935
Jurisdiction Scope	Original, appellate, advisory, and SLP jurisdiction	Limited to federal disputes and constitutional interpretation
Fundamental Rights	Guardian and enforcer of fundamental rights under Article 32	No specific role in protecting individual rights
Judicial Review Power	Comprehensive judicial review including basic structure doctrine	Limited judicial review under colonial constitutional framework

The Supreme Court of India represents a significant evolution from the Federal Court, with vastly expanded powers and jurisdiction. While the Federal Court was primarily concerned with federal disputes under colonial rule, the Supreme Court serves as the guardian of the Constitution and fundamental rights in independent India. The Supreme Court's advisory jurisdiction, comprehensive judicial review powers, and role in protecting individual rights through Article 32 distinguish it fundamentally from its predecessor. The transition from Federal Court to Supreme Court symbolizes India's transformation from a colonial dominion to a sovereign democratic republic.

Also build Paper II skills

Dense constitutional and IR passages mirror CSAT-style comprehension and argument evaluation—build those skills in parallel. CSAT hub.

• Valid & invalid arguments
• Syllogisms
• Critical reasoning